Where is Elisa McNabney Now? 2024 Update & Background

Elisa McNabney, born Laren Renee Sims on January 20, 1966, in Attleboro, Massachusetts, before moving to Florida, led a life marked by deception, criminal activity, and ultimately, tragedy. Despite showing early signs of intelligence and potential—having been a cheerleader and an excellent student with an IQ of 140—her life took a series of dark turns that would lead her down a path far removed from the promise of her early years.

Early Life and Downward Spiral

Sims’s early life in Florida seemed to set her up for success; however, she dropped out of high school and soon after began engaging in criminal activities, including theft and fraud. Her life of crime escalated in complexity and severity, leading to her arrest for stealing a L’Oreal hair color kit and subsequent probation violations. These early encounters with the law were just the beginning of what would become a long history of using aliases and running from the law. Sims’s penchant for deceit and manipulation became a defining characteristic of her life, leading her to assume at least 38 different aliases over the years.

Meeting Larry McNabney and the Path to Murder

Sims met Larry McNabney in 1995 when she applied for a job at his law office in Las Vegas. Despite a significant embezzlement scandal that forced McNabney to close his offices and relocate his practice to Sacramento, California, Sims managed to charm her way into becoming McNabney’s fifth wife in 1996. This marriage marked the beginning of her most audacious and deadly scheme. On September 10, 2001, Sims, now going by the name Elisa McNabney, and her accomplice, Sarah Dutra, poisoned Larry McNabney with a horse tranquilizer. The following months involved a complex cover-up that included storing McNabney’s body in a refrigerator and eventually burying him in a vineyard, all while Sims liquidated his assets and prepared to flee.

The Discovery and Manhunt

The discovery of Larry McNabney’s body in February 2002 in a vineyard near Linden, California, set off a nationwide manhunt for Elisa McNabney. By then, she had vanished, leaving behind a trail of deceit and a series of aliases. McNabney’s murder and the subsequent investigation captivated the nation, exposing the depth of Elisa McNabney’s manipulation and criminality. Her life on the run was marked by a series of evasions and close calls with the law until her eventual capture in Florida in March 2002, where she had been hiding under yet another alias.

Elisa McNabney’s story came to a tragic end on March 31, 2002, when she was found dead in her jail cell in Florida, having taken her own life. Her suicide left many questions unanswered and brought a somber close to a case that had shocked and captivated the public. In her suicide note, McNabney attempted to provide for her children and expressed a desire to spare them the pain of her trial, highlighting the complex and conflicted nature of her character.

Legacy and Reflections

Elisa McNabney’s life story serves as a cautionary tale about the depths of deceit and the devastating impact of manipulation and crime on victims and their families. Her intelligence and potential, which could have led to a very different life, instead spiraled into a life of crime that ended in tragedy. The case remains a subject of interest for those studying criminal psychology and the justice system, offering insights into the complexities of human behavior, the consequences of criminal actions, and the far-reaching impact of deceit.

More 20/20: Hell in Heels

More Feature Articles

Avatar photo

Ryan Gill

Ryan is a passionate follower of true crime television programs, reporting on and providing in-depth investigations on mysteries in the criminal world.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *