Site icon 20/20 Tonight

Who Is Andrew Isaac Griffin? The Man Convicted of Murdering Thomas and Angela Strussion – 2026 Update

Andrew Isaac Griffin is an Oklahoma man convicted of murdering Ohio couple Thomas and Angela Strussion in September 2021, following a dispute involving a failed restaurant business partnership. The killings, which took place inside the couple’s Belmont County home, became the subject of a lengthy investigation that culminated in guilty verdicts in November 2026.

The case closely matches the details promoted for ABC’s 20/20 episode “Murder on the Menu,” airing Friday, November 20, 2026, at 9/8c. The programme examines a married couple murdered in their home and a recent verdict, although the network has not confirmed the Strussion case in the promotional information available before broadcast.

Griffin, 34 at the time of his trial, had been involved in plans to open a Salsa Joe’s restaurant in West Virginia with Thomas Strussion. Their business relationship deteriorated, and Griffin was removed from the partnership.

Prosecutors argued that Griffin developed a grievance against Thomas and planned to kill him. During the trial, a longtime friend named Brett Cole testified that he helped Griffin prepare for the attack, including obtaining a motorcycle and arranging to conceal Griffin’s movements.

According to Cole, Griffin travelled to the Strussions’ home and shot Thomas before killing Angela when she reacted to the attack. Cole said the original plan had targeted Thomas alone.

The couple’s home was set on fire after the shootings, killing their two dogs and a cat. Investigators determined that the blaze was deliberate, and prosecutors alleged that Griffin had started it.

Griffin was arrested in Hawaii in February 2025, more than three years after the murders. He pleaded not guilty and stood trial in Belmont County Common Pleas Court in October and November 2026.

On November 4, 2026, a jury found him guilty of two counts of aggravated murder and one count of aggravated arson.

As of November 19, 2026, Griffin is awaiting sentencing, which is scheduled for December 1. No final prison sentence has been imposed, and his precise current detention facility has not been established through the available information.

Who Is Andrew Isaac Griffin?

Andrew Isaac Griffin is a 34-year-old man associated with Oklahoma who was convicted of murdering Thomas and Angela Strussion in Belmont County, Ohio.

He had been involved in a restaurant business partnership with Thomas before the killings.

The proposed venture concerned opening a Salsa Joe’s restaurant in West Virginia.

The partnership deteriorated, and Griffin was removed from the arrangement.

His name became central to the murder investigation because prosecutors alleged that the failed business relationship provided a motive for violence.

The available public reporting provides limited information about Griffin’s childhood, education, employment history and family background outside the restaurant venture.

What is documented is that he had a longstanding friendship with Brett Cole, who would become a key prosecution witness.

Cole testified that he had known Griffin since childhood and regarded him as a younger brother.

Griffin’s involvement in the restaurant dispute and the alleged murder plot became the focus of his criminal trial.

Andrew Griffin’s Connection to Thomas Strussion

Griffin became connected to Thomas Strussion through plans to open a Salsa Joe’s restaurant in West Virginia.

The venture involved a business partnership that was intended to establish a restaurant operation.

According to testimony presented during the murder trial, the relationship began with expectations that the partners would work together.

The arrangement deteriorated, and Griffin began expressing complaints about Thomas.

Griffin was removed from the partnership.

The breakdown became important after the murders because prosecutors argued that it created a motive for Griffin to target Thomas.

Brett Cole testified that Griffin had discussed the dispute with him.

Cole said Griffin believed Thomas was placing him in danger over financial obligations connected to the restaurant.

The prosecution used the failed partnership to explain the background to the alleged murder plot.

What Went Wrong With the Salsa Joe’s Restaurant Partnership?

The proposed Salsa Joe’s restaurant in West Virginia became a source of conflict between Griffin and Thomas Strussion.

Cole testified that Griffin complained about the business arrangement and the circumstances surrounding the restaurant premises.

According to Cole, Griffin claimed that the building leased for the restaurant was owned by people he described as mobsters.

Griffin also alleged that Thomas owed money to those individuals.

Cole said Griffin believed Thomas was attempting to shift responsibility for the debt onto him.

The account suggested that Griffin feared being targeted over money associated with the business.

These claims were statements attributed to Griffin through Cole’s testimony.

They did not establish that Thomas had arranged a threat against Griffin or that organised crime figures controlled the restaurant property.

The prosecution presented the conversations as evidence of Griffin’s grievances and alleged motive.

Why Griffin Believed Thomas Was a Threat

Cole testified that Griffin believed Thomas was responsible for placing him in danger.

The alleged dispute concerned the restaurant venture and financial obligations associated with the leased premises.

According to Cole, Griffin claimed that Thomas had attempted to arrange a killing against him.

Cole described Griffin’s perception of the dispute as a situation in which he believed he might be killed unless he acted first.

The testimony became important because it explained the reasoning Griffin allegedly gave when discussing violence against Thomas.

Prosecutors presented the dispute as part of the motive for murder.

The claims did not establish that Thomas had threatened Griffin or arranged violence against him.

They were allegations attributed to Griffin and described by Cole during the trial.

The prosecution argued that Griffin’s beliefs and resentment developed into a plan to kill Thomas.

The jury considered the testimony alongside other evidence presented during the proceedings.

Andrew Griffin’s Friendship With Brett Cole

Griffin and Brett Cole had known each other since childhood.

Cole described Griffin as someone he regarded as a younger brother.

The relationship became significant because Cole testified that Griffin discussed the restaurant dispute and plans to kill Thomas with him.

Cole acknowledged that he had participated in planning the attack.

He described conversations concerning transportation, concealment and how the killing might be carried out.

At the time of the trial, Cole was serving three life sentences in federal prison for unrelated sexual offences.

He testified under an immunity agreement.

Prosecutors agreed not to charge him in connection with the Strussion murders in exchange for truthful testimony.

They also agreed to seek his transfer to a federal facility closer to Texas.

The defence questioned whether those benefits influenced his account.

The Alleged Plan to Murder Thomas Strussion

Cole testified that Griffin discussed killing Thomas before travelling to Ohio.

He described conversations about how the attack could be carried out.

According to Cole, the plan involved travelling to the Strussions’ home and shooting Thomas.

Cole acknowledged helping Griffin prepare for the proposed crime.

The preparations included discussions about transportation and avoiding identification.

Cole testified that Griffin wanted to borrow his truck for the journey.

He refused and suggested using a motorcycle.

The prosecution presented the testimony as evidence that the killing had been planned rather than arising from a confrontation without preparation.

The account became important to the aggravated murder charges because it concerned the alleged intent and planning behind the attack.

Why Griffin Used a Motorcycle

Cole testified that he advised Griffin to use a motorcycle to travel to Ohio.

He described discussions about concealing the vehicle’s identification and reducing the likelihood of attracting police attention.

Cole said he travelled to Texas to purchase a motorcycle on Griffin’s behalf.

The arrangement formed part of the preparations he described to jurors.

According to his testimony, Griffin had wanted to borrow Cole’s truck.

Cole refused to provide the vehicle.

The motorcycle became an alternative.

Prosecutors used the account to support their allegation that Griffin had made preparations before the killings.

The testimony also demonstrated that the alleged plan extended beyond statements of anger towards Thomas.

It involved practical arrangements connected to the proposed attack.

The Attempt to Conceal Griffin’s Movements

Cole testified that he agreed to help create the impression that Griffin remained elsewhere while travelling to Ohio.

The arrangement involved keeping Griffin’s phone during the journey.

Cole described taking pictures through Snapchat and communicating with Griffin’s wife.

The purpose, according to his testimony, was to make it appear that Griffin had not left.

The prosecution presented the account as evidence of planning and concealment.

It became relevant because investigators had to establish Griffin’s movements during the period surrounding the murders.

The defence challenged Cole’s credibility and questioned his motives for cooperating.

Jurors had to assess whether his testimony was reliable.

The alleged communications arrangement formed part of the prosecution’s reconstruction of events before the killings.

What Happened on September 21, 2021?

On September 21, 2021, Thomas and Angela Strussion were killed inside their Belmont County home.

Thomas was 52 years old, while Angela was 49.

Both suffered fatal gunshot wounds.

The residence was set on fire after the shootings.

The blaze also killed the couple’s two dogs and a cat.

Investigators examined the damaged property and began reconstructing the attack.

The prosecution alleged that Griffin had travelled to Ohio to kill Thomas.

Cole’s testimony provided an account of the events inside the home, based on what he said Griffin told him.

The jury would consider that account during the November 2026 trial.

How Griffin Allegedly Entered the Strussions’ Home

Cole testified that Griffin described entering the Strussions’ home while the couple were having drinks.

The account suggested that Griffin approached the victims inside their residence.

According to Cole, Griffin shot Thomas in the arm during the initial confrontation.

Angela reacted to the shooting.

Cole testified that Griffin then shot Angela multiple times.

After shooting Angela, Griffin turned back towards Thomas and killed him.

The testimony provided prosecutors with an account of how both victims died.

Cole was not an eyewitness inside the home.

His description was based on what he claimed Griffin had told him.

The jury considered the account alongside the physical evidence establishing that the couple had been shot.

Why Angela Strussion Was Also Killed

One of the most significant aspects of Cole’s testimony concerned Angela Strussion.

He told the jury that the original plan had been to kill Thomas.

Angela was not supposed to be harmed, according to his account.

Cole said Griffin described shooting Angela after she reacted to the attack on her husband.

The testimony suggested that Angela became a victim during the confrontation rather than as part of the original alleged plan.

Angela was 49 years old when she died.

The prosecution established that she had suffered fatal gunshot wounds inside her home.

Her murder became a separate aggravated murder charge.

The jury convicted Griffin of killing her.

The verdict established his criminal responsibility for both deaths.

The Fire Set After the Murders

After Thomas and Angela were shot, their home was set on fire.

Investigators determined that the blaze was deliberate.

Prosecutors alleged that Griffin started the fire after the killings.

The damage complicated the forensic investigation and created additional destruction at the scene.

Cole testified that Griffin had discussed making the crime appear to be a robbery.

According to Cole, setting the house on fire was not part of the original plan.

Cole said he had warned Griffin against using fire.

The prosecution used the testimony to explain the alleged sequence of events after the shootings.

The fire became the basis of the aggravated arson charge.

On November 4, 2026, the jury found Griffin guilty of that offence.

The Deaths of the Strussions’ Pets

The fire at the Strussions’ home also killed their two dogs and a cat.

The animals were inside the residence when the blaze occurred.

Their deaths added to the destruction caused by the attack.

The fire damaged the couple’s home and complicated the investigation.

Prosecutors alleged that Griffin had started the blaze after murdering Thomas and Angela.

The deaths of the animals formed part of the factual background to the aggravated arson prosecution.

The verdicts announced in November 2026 concerned two counts of aggravated murder and one count of aggravated arson.

The available reporting does not establish separate animal cruelty convictions arising from the pets’ deaths.

The fire remained important because it followed the shootings and was alleged to have been intended to alter or destroy evidence.

The Investigation Into the Double Murder

The discovery of the Strussions’ bodies prompted a major homicide investigation.

Authorities had to determine how the couple had been killed and establish the origin of the fire.

The investigation involved examining evidence from the damaged residence.

Forensic specialists worked to identify evidence associated with the shootings despite the effects of the blaze.

Investigators examined the couple’s personal and professional relationships.

Thomas’s former restaurant partnership became an important lead.

The case involved the Belmont County Sheriff’s Office, the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation and the FBI.

Authorities examined the business dispute and evidence concerning Griffin’s movements.

The investigation continued for more than three years before Griffin was arrested.

Why Andrew Griffin Was Not Arrested Until 2025

Thomas and Angela were murdered in September 2021.

Griffin was not arrested until February 2025.

The interval reflected the length of the investigation into the double homicide and arson.

Authorities examined evidence from the damaged home and the couple’s business relationships.

The case involved allegations of planning and attempts to conceal Griffin’s movements.

Investigators also had to assess testimony from people connected to the alleged plot.

The investigation required coordination between local, state and federal authorities.

The case extended across several states because Griffin was associated with Oklahoma and was arrested in Hawaii.

The prosecution developed a case that reached trial in October and November 2026.

The verdict came more than five years after the murders.

Andrew Griffin Arrested in Hawaii

Authorities arrested Griffin in Hawaii in February 2025.

The arrest came approximately three years and five months after the murders.

Griffin had previously been involved in the restaurant partnership with Thomas.

Investigators alleged that the failed business relationship provided a motive for the killings.

The arrest marked a significant development in a case that had remained under investigation for years.

Griffin was returned to Ohio to face prosecution.

He was charged with offences arising from the murders and the fire at the Strussions’ residence.

The charges included aggravated murder and aggravated arson.

Griffin pleaded not guilty.

The case proceeded through pretrial hearings before reaching a jury in Belmont County Common Pleas Court.

The Charges Against Andrew Griffin

Griffin faced criminal charges arising from the deaths of Thomas and Angela Strussion and the fire at their home.

The prosecution included aggravated murder allegations involving both victims.

He also faced an aggravated arson charge connected to the deliberate fire.

The charges reflected the prosecution’s theory that Griffin had planned to kill Thomas, murdered both spouses and set the residence ablaze.

Aggravated murder is among the most serious homicide offences under Ohio law.

The prosecution was required to prove the statutory elements of each charge beyond a reasonable doubt.

The defence contested the allegations and challenged the evidence.

The jury would determine whether Griffin was criminally responsible for the killings and the fire.

The final verdict included convictions on two counts of aggravated murder and one count of aggravated arson.

Andrew Griffin’s Murder Trial in October and November 2026

Griffin’s trial took place in Belmont County Common Pleas Court in late October and early November 2026.

The proceedings involved testimony concerning the restaurant partnership, the alleged murder plot and the circumstances of the shootings.

Prosecutors presented evidence linking Griffin to the crime and called Cole to describe the planning.

Cole testified about his friendship with Griffin and the conversations they had concerning Thomas.

He also described helping Griffin obtain a motorcycle and assisting with arrangements intended to conceal his movements.

The prosecution used his testimony to establish the alleged planning behind the murders.

The defence challenged Cole’s credibility, including his criminal history and the benefits he received for cooperating.

Jurors were required to assess the testimony alongside the other evidence presented during the trial.

The proceedings concluded with guilty verdicts on November 4.

Brett Cole’s Testimony Against Griffin

Cole’s testimony became one of the most significant parts of the prosecution’s case.

He admitted helping plan the killing of Thomas Strussion.

He described discussions concerning transportation, concealment and the intended attack.

Cole also testified about Griffin’s account of what happened inside the victims’ home.

The testimony was unusual because Cole acknowledged involvement in planning a murder while denying that he wanted Griffin to carry it out.

He said he had hoped Griffin would abandon the plan.

The defence questioned that explanation.

Attorneys highlighted his criminal convictions, immunity agreement and prior statements to investigators.

The jury had to decide how much weight to give his account.

The prosecution maintained that the testimony helped establish the planning and execution of the murders.

Why the Defence Challenged Brett Cole’s Credibility

Griffin’s defence questioned Cole about his involvement in the alleged plot and his reasons for testifying.

Cole was serving three life sentences in federal prison for unrelated sexual crimes.

He had received an immunity agreement protecting him from prosecution in the Strussion case in exchange for truthful testimony.

Prosecutors had also agreed to seek his transfer to a prison closer to Texas.

The defence argued that those benefits gave him reasons to cooperate.

Attorneys also questioned money deposited into his prison commissary account.

Cole said the payments compensated him for income he lost while away from his usual prison facility.

The defence highlighted that Cole had initially told investigators he knew nothing about the killings.

Those contradictions became part of the jury’s assessment of his reliability.

The case demonstrated the importance of evaluating testimony from cooperating witnesses who have admitted criminal involvement.

Andrew Griffin Found Guilty on November 4, 2026

On November 4, 2026, a Belmont County jury found Griffin guilty of murdering Thomas and Angela Strussion.

The verdict included two counts of aggravated murder.

Jurors also found him guilty of aggravated arson.

The decision followed the presentation of evidence concerning the failed restaurant partnership, the alleged murder plot and the fire at the victims’ home.

The verdict established Griffin’s criminal responsibility for both deaths.

It also established his guilt in connection with the deliberate fire.

The convictions represented the outcome of a prosecution that began more than five years after the murders.

The case had required an extended investigation and a trial involving contested witness testimony.

The jury’s decision resolved the question of guilt at the trial level.

Sentencing remained outstanding.

What Sentence Will Andrew Griffin Receive?

Griffin was convicted on November 4, 2026, of two counts of aggravated murder and one count of aggravated arson.

His sentencing hearing is scheduled for December 1, 2026.

As of November 19, no final sentence has been imposed.

The convictions expose Griffin to substantial punishment under Ohio law.

The precise sentence will depend on the applicable statutes and the court’s sentencing determination.

It would be inaccurate to report that Griffin has received a particular prison term before the hearing takes place.

The sentencing proceedings may also provide an opportunity for relatives of the victims to describe the impact of the crimes.

Any sentence imposed could be subject to further legal proceedings, including appeal.

The documented outcome is a guilty verdict, with sentencing pending.

Where Is Andrew Griffin Now in November 2026?

Andrew Isaac Griffin is awaiting sentencing following his November 4, 2026, convictions for two counts of aggravated murder and one count of aggravated arson.

He was 34 years old during the trial.

His sentencing hearing is scheduled for December 1, 2026.

The available information does not establish his precise current detention facility.

Because sentencing has not taken place, it would be inaccurate to identify him as serving a specific prison term.

The convictions remain the established outcome of the jury trial.

Griffin’s legal status could be affected by post-trial motions or appeals.

No such proceedings should be treated as having changed the verdict without confirmation.

The case remains significant because the conviction followed a years-long investigation into the murders of two people inside their home.

Could Andrew Griffin Appeal His Conviction?

Griffin’s convictions may be subject to appeal after the court completes the sentencing process.

An appeal would involve legal challenges to aspects of the proceedings rather than a new jury determination of guilt.

Potential issues in criminal appeals can include the admission of evidence, jury instructions or other questions of law.

The available information does not establish that Griffin has filed an appeal.

His sentencing hearing remains scheduled for December 1, 2026.

The convictions stand as the documented outcome of the trial.

Any future appellate proceedings would require examination of the court record.

A conviction should not be described as overturned or modified without a confirmed judicial decision.

The next established stage of the case is sentencing.

The Significance of Griffin’s Conviction

Griffin’s conviction brought a major development in a case that had remained under investigation for years.

Thomas and Angela Strussion were murdered in September 2021.

Griffin was not arrested until February 2025.

The trial did not take place until October and November 2026.

The prosecution relied on evidence concerning the restaurant dispute, the alleged murder plot and the fire at the couple’s home.

Cole’s testimony provided an account of preparations and the circumstances of the shootings.

The defence challenged his reliability and motives for cooperating.

The jury considered the evidence and found Griffin guilty of both murders and aggravated arson.

The verdict established criminal responsibility for the killings.

Sentencing remains the final major stage of the trial court proceedings.

Andrew Griffin’s Case and ABC’s 20/20 Murder on the Menu

ABC has promoted 20/20: Murder on the Menu as an investigation into a married couple murdered in their own home.

The teaser refers to a recent verdict and new details emerging from the case.

Those descriptions closely match the murders of Thomas and Angela Strussion and Griffin’s November 4, 2026, conviction.

The restaurant connection also corresponds to the programme’s title.

Griffin’s former business partnership with Thomas involved a proposed Salsa Joe’s restaurant in West Virginia.

The timing of the verdict and the broadcast provides a further connection.

However, the promotional information available before transmission does not expressly identify the Strussions or Griffin.

The connection should therefore be treated as a strong match rather than confirmed programme information.

A full ABC synopsis or the broadcast itself would establish the episode’s subject.

What Happened to Andrew Isaac Griffin?

Andrew Isaac Griffin was a former restaurant business partner of Thomas Strussion.

The two men had been involved in plans to open a Salsa Joe’s restaurant in West Virginia.

Their business relationship deteriorated, and Griffin was removed from the partnership.

Prosecutors alleged that Griffin developed a grievance against Thomas and planned to kill him.

On September 21, 2021, Thomas and Angela Strussion were shot to death inside their Belmont County, Ohio, home.

The residence was set on fire after the shootings, killing the couple’s two dogs and a cat.

During Griffin’s trial, Brett Cole testified that he had helped plan the attack.

Cole said the original plan was to kill Thomas, but Angela was shot after reacting to the attack on her husband.

Griffin was arrested in Hawaii in February 2025.

He pleaded not guilty and stood trial in Belmont County Common Pleas Court in October and November 2026.

On November 4, the jury found him guilty of two counts of aggravated murder and one count of aggravated arson.

His sentencing is scheduled for December 1, 2026.

As of November 19, 2026, Griffin is a convicted defendant awaiting sentencing. His precise detention facility and eventual prison term have not been confirmed.

His case closely matches the promotional details for ABC’s 20/20: Murder on the Menu, airing Friday, November 20, 2026, at 9/8c, although the network has not confirmed the connection in the programme information available before broadcast.

More “Murder on the Menu”

More Feature Articles 

Exit mobile version