What Happened to Tracie Hawlett & J.B. Beasley? 2024 Update & Background

Tracie Hawlett and J.B. Beasley were both 17-year-old high school seniors from the small city of Ozark, Alabama, at the time of their tragic deaths. Known for their bright personalities and aspirations, both girls were navigating the typical challenges and excitements of teenage life, looking forward to their senior year of high school. Tracie was described by those who knew her as a compassionate and vibrant young woman, eager to contribute positively to her community. J.B., similarly, was remembered for her infectious energy and her dreams of future success, which were deeply rooted in her close relationships with friends and family.

The lives of these young individuals were intertwined not only by their personal friendship but also by their shared experiences and the community they were a part of. Both girls were active in their schools and had a wide circle of friends. The news of their disappearance and subsequent murder deeply shook their families, friends, and acquaintances, leaving a permanent mark on the fabric of their local community.

The Disappearance and Tragic End

On July 31, 1999, Tracie Hawlett and J.B. Beasley left for a party in southeastern Alabama. The evening was meant to be a celebration, particularly for J.B., who was celebrating her birthday. However, as the night progressed, both girls failed to return home, sparking immediate concern among their families and friends. The following day, their worst fears were realized when the bodies of both girls were discovered in the trunk of Beasley’s black Mazda along a road in Ozark. Each had been shot in the head, a brutal end to their young lives. This discovery launched an extensive investigation, as local law enforcement sought to unravel the circumstances leading to their tragic deaths.

The case quickly captured the attention of the local community and the media, given the mysterious and horrific nature of the crime. For nearly two decades, the murders remained unsolved, with multiple leads and suspects but no conclusive evidence to charge anyone. The lack of closure prolonged the agony for the families involved and the community at large, maintaining a cloud of fear and uncertainty over Ozark.

Breakthrough in the Case and Arrest of Coley McCraney

The turning point in the investigation came in 2019, nearly 20 years after the murders, when a new technique involving genetic genealogy was used. This method, which had gained attention after its successful application in the Golden State Killer case, provided the necessary breakthrough in the Hawlett-Beasley case. DNA evidence collected from the crime scene was analyzed and compared with genetic profiles available in a public genealogy database, leading to a familial match. This match pointed to Coley McCraney, a local truck driver and preacher with no prior criminal record, as the suspect.

McCraney’s arrest in March 2019 came as a shock to many who knew him as a respected member of the community and a man of faith. Following his arrest, he was charged with capital murder. During the trial, McCraney maintained his innocence regarding the murders, although he admitted to having had consensual sexual contact with J.B. Beasley on the night of her death. His defense highlighted the lack of direct evidence linking him to the killings, aside from the controversial DNA match.

Trial Outcomes and Sentencing

The trial of Coley McCraney was closely followed by both the local community and national media, given the cold case’s notoriety and the implications of using genetic genealogy in criminal investigations. In a significant development, McCraney was found guilty of capital murder. The jury, tasked with deciding his fate, ultimately sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of parole. This sentence was handed down after careful consideration of the evidence and the gravity of the crime.

The sentencing brought a mix of relief and renewed grief to the families of Tracie Hawlett and J.B. Beasley. While it did not bring back their loved ones, there was a sense of justice being served, albeit decades later. The outcome of the trial also sparked broader discussions on the ethical use of genetic genealogy in law enforcement, privacy concerns, and the potential for future cases to be solved using similar methods.

Legacy and Community Impact

The murders of Tracie Hawlett and J.B. Beasley left a lasting impact on the community of Ozark. The resolution of the case did not erase the pain or the memories, but it did provide some answers to the haunting questions that lingered for years. The legacy of the two young women continues to be remembered by those who knew them, with community memorials and advocacy for improved safety measures for teenagers.

Their case has also contributed to a broader dialogue on the capabilities and limitations of forensic science, particularly the use of DNA in solving crimes. The story of Tracie Hawlett and J.B. Beasley serves as a poignant reminder of the unresolved cases waiting for justice and the continuous evolution of technology in aiding these efforts.

More 20/20: Forever 17

More Feature Articles

Avatar photo

Ryan Gill

Ryan is a passionate follower of true crime television programs, reporting on and providing in-depth investigations on mysteries in the criminal world.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *